Authorities have arrested four roommates in connection with the tragic shooting death of a 17-year-old girl northwest of Cedar City on Friday night. The suspects told investigators they believed they were being stalked by the driver of a red pickup truck they had noticed on multiple occasions in their neighborhood and around town.

Iron County Sheriff Ken Carpenter provided additional details about the incident on Sunday, stating that the suspects claimed it was the red truck itself—not the occupants inside—that sparked their suspicion and ultimately led to the fatal confrontation.

“Through the interview process with the suspects, it was revealed that they had observed a red pickup truck at various locations, including Walmart and Lin’s grocery store, as well as within their neighborhood,” Carpenter said. “Believing they were being stalked, they decided to take matters into their own hands when they spotted the vehicle again and pursued it.”

According to investigators, the pursuit ended tragically near 4200 West Midvalley Road when the suspects’ vehicle pulled up alongside the red pickup and a passenger fired twelve rounds into the driver’s side, fatally wounding the teenage driver.

Authorities identified 23-year-old Michael E. Witucki as the driver of the suspects’ vehicle, a 2018 black Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck registered in his name. His accomplice, 23-year-old Ethan A. Galloway, admitted to being the front seat passenger and firing the shots. Carpenter noted that the suspects repeatedly referred to the driver of the red pickup truck as “he,” indicating they were unaware that the victims were two young women.

Investigators determined that the victim, who previously resided in the neighborhood, had been visiting friends in the area that night.

The other two suspects, 21-year-old Aldric S. Felipe and 22-year-old Matthew D. Sorber-Petrie, were also arrested and face charges related to their involvement. While they remained at their residence during the shooting, authorities say they were aware of the plan and provided material support.

During a search of the suspects’ residence, multiple firearms were recovered, including at least two AR-15 rifles, a shotgun, a .308 rifle, and a .22 caliber revolver. Additionally, spent .223-caliber shell casings matching those found at the crime scene were discovered hidden in a container inside the townhome.

The suspects, who moved to Cedar City from California approximately one year ago, were arrested on Saturday afternoon. Three were taken into custody by Iron County Metro SWAT officers at their townhome located at 1645 N. 3200 West, while the fourth suspect was apprehended at his workplace. All suspects were compliant during the arrests.

Michael E. Witucki and Ethan A. Galloway each face multiple charges, including:

• One count of murder, a first-degree felony
• Twelve counts of felony discharge of a firearm, first-degree felonies
• One count of obstruction of justice, a second-degree felony
• One count of possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person, a third-degree felony
• One count of possession of marijuana, a class B misdemeanor

Aldric S. Felipe and Matthew D. Sorber-Petrie face the following charges:

• One count of obstruction of justice, a second-degree felony
• One count of possession of a firearm by a restricted person, a third-degree felony
• One count of possession of marijuana, a class B misdemeanor

Sheriff Carpenter stated that the Iron County Attorney’s Office would review the charges and may adjust them accordingly.

The investigation remains active, with detectives following up on additional leads. Carpenter expressed appreciation for the community’s assistance, noting that witness statements and surveillance footage played a crucial role in solving the case.

“The information provided by witnesses was vital in bringing these individuals to justice,” Carpenter said, encouraging anyone with further information to contact the sheriff’s office at 435-876-7500.

The Iron County School District released a statement mourning the loss of the victim, identified as KayLee Dutton. District spokesperson Shauna Lund offered condolences to her family and friends, emphasizing the availability of counseling resources for students and staff at Parowan and Canyon View High Schools.

“Our thoughts and condolences are with her family and friends. This is an incredibly difficult time for our community,” Lund stated.

Sheriff Carpenter extended gratitude to all agencies assisting in the investigation, including local law enforcement, fire departments, and emergency responders.

“We are dedicated to ensuring public safety and holding those responsible for this tragic act of unprovoked violence accountable,” Carpenter said. “Our heartfelt condolences continue to go out to the victim’s loved ones.”

This report is based on information provided by law enforcement officials and court records. All individuals arrested are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.